I didn't want Andy to win either, but of the 3 that were left, I think he played the best game. Not a game I agree with, but he did work hard to get to the end and keep everyone from finding out what a rat he was.
I would have preferred Judd to win America's Favorite just because I think he needs the money more than Elissa does and he brought some levity and laughter to a season that was pretty horrible...I was happy though to hear that she said she would be putting most of the money to a good cause, I believe she has a charity or something she's trying to get started.