While nothing against Esqueleto or other players like him, I personally don't think giving out your items to other people constitutes a Gold Star Reward Pin/Cl Position.
These are for people who go above and beyond to help the community, in more ways than just handing out items for free. It's for people who run Facebook groups to keep people inform, run programs like the MyVMK Pal client to provide different features for the game, and who are always ready and willing to help others in a variety of ways.
While giving out items for free may factor into this, I know of people who have given out items before, but as being helpful towards the community, they aren't.
Once again, no disrespect towards Esqueleto or any other member who willingly gives out their items.