obamacare/national healthcare

Jerimiah

Well-Known Member
#21
I'm from Canada and its obvious that our healthcare system is much more efficient and accessible than in America and its good that people are trying to change the system in America but obamacare really isn't the answer. It was all talk and no pay-out. With all the difficulties they had it ended up making it a lot harder for people to get healthcare and it just wasn't what people expected it to be.
i mean its not like some towns in canada have doctors with 25k (plus rent) a year salaries and they only take on 4 new patients every 6 months (via a lottery)...

and its not like cancer patients, etc come to the US for medical care and pay for it because it's better and/or faster...
I'm guessing this is sarcasm and if it is then you literally have no idea what you're talking about.
 

Whispered

Well-Known Member
#22
I'm from Canada and its obvious that our healthcare system is much more efficient and accessible than in America and its good that people are trying to change the system in America but obamacare really isn't the answer. It was all talk and no pay-out. With all the difficulties they had it ended up making it a lot harder for people to get healthcare and it just wasn't what people expected it to be.
i mean its not like some towns in canada have doctors with 25k (plus rent) a year salaries and they only take on 4 new patients every 6 months (via a lottery)...

and its not like cancer patients, etc come to the US for medical care and pay for it because it's better and/or faster...
I'm guessing this is sarcasm and if it is then you literally have no idea what you're talking about.
it's not sarcasm.

http://dailycaller.com/2012/07/11/report-thousands-fled-canada-for-health-care-in-2011/

http://blog.heritage.org/2010/02/09/the-canadian-patients’-remedy-for-health-care-go-to-america/

Need I provide more? I personally think the first report, done by a Canadian organization themselves, is the most interesting. You?
 
Last edited:

Goddess

Where did 4 years go?!
#23
I'm from Canada and its obvious that our healthcare system is much more efficient and accessible than in America and its good that people are trying to change the system in America but obamacare really isn't the answer. It was all talk and no pay-out. With all the difficulties they had it ended up making it a lot harder for people to get healthcare and it just wasn't what people expected it to be.
i mean its not like some towns in canada have doctors with 25k (plus rent) a year salaries and they only take on 4 new patients every 6 months (via a lottery)...

and its not like cancer patients, etc come to the US for medical care and pay for it because it's better and/or faster...
I'm guessing this is sarcasm and if it is then you literally have no idea what you're talking about.
it's not sarcasm.

http://dailycaller.com/2012/07/11/report-thousands-fled-canada-for-health-care-in-2011/

http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/21/3/19.long

http://blog.heritage.org/2010/02/09/the-canadian-patients’-remedy-for-health-care-go-to-america/

Need I provide more? I personally think the first report, done by a Canadian organization themselves, is the most interesting. You?
I'm sure that's the case in some parts of Canada but not all. And the same in the US, some parts of the US have wait times for specialists that rival those numbers.

Some specialists I've had to see in New Jersey have a 6 month waiting list to get in to see the doctor. We have our problems as well. :sulk:

I've done my research on Canadian healthcare, and wait times to see doctors because I'll be moving there within this year or the next. And nearly everyone I know here has been telling me this same story that in Canada you have to wait a long, long time to get in for appointments with some doctors. And after looking in to it, surprisingly it's not as difficult as people think it is, or as long. It's like a myth that Canada's healthcare being what it is means there's less health treatment opportunities available. Like I said in some parts of Canada this is true, but not all parts, and according to research done where I plan to live, this isn't really the case.
 
Last edited:

Monorail

Well-Known Member
#24
I'm from Canada and its obvious that our healthcare system is much more efficient and accessible than in America and its good that people are trying to change the system in America but obamacare really isn't the answer. It was all talk and no pay-out. With all the difficulties they had it ended up making it a lot harder for people to get healthcare and it just wasn't what people expected it to be.
i mean its not like some towns in canada have doctors with 25k (plus rent) a year salaries and they only take on 4 new patients every 6 months (via a lottery)...

and its not like cancer patients, etc come to the US for medical care and pay for it because it's better and/or faster...
I'm guessing this is sarcasm and if it is then you literally have no idea what you're talking about.
it's not sarcasm.

http://dailycaller.com/2012/07/11/report-thousands-fled-canada-for-health-care-in-2011/

http://blog.heritage.org/2010/02/09/the-canadian-patients’-remedy-for-health-care-go-to-america/

Need I provide more? I personally think the first report, done by a Canadian organization themselves, is the most interesting. You?

Maybe I'm missing something, but your second link seems to be against the point your making.

From the link:
"Surprisingly few Canadians travel to the United States for health care, despite the persistence of the myth."

http://m.content.healthaffairs.org/content/21/3/19.long


Also could just be me, but the third link is broken.
 
Last edited:

Whispered

Well-Known Member
#25
I'm from Canada and its obvious that our healthcare system is much more efficient and accessible than in America and its good that people are trying to change the system in America but obamacare really isn't the answer. It was all talk and no pay-out. With all the difficulties they had it ended up making it a lot harder for people to get healthcare and it just wasn't what people expected it to be.
i mean its not like some towns in canada have doctors with 25k (plus rent) a year salaries and they only take on 4 new patients every 6 months (via a lottery)...

and its not like cancer patients, etc come to the US for medical care and pay for it because it's better and/or faster...
I'm guessing this is sarcasm and if it is then you literally have no idea what you're talking about.
it's not sarcasm.

http://dailycaller.com/2012/07/11/report-thousands-fled-canada-for-health-care-in-2011/

http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/21/3/19.long

http://blog.heritage.org/2010/02/09/the-canadian-patients’-remedy-for-health-care-go-to-america/

Need I provide more? I personally think the first report, done by a Canadian organization themselves, is the most interesting. You?
I'm sure that's the case in some parts of Canada but not all. And the same in the US, we pay for our healthcare here, yet some parts of the US have wait times for specialists that rival those numbers.

Some specialists I've had to see in New Jersey have a 6 month waiting list to get in to see the doctor. We have our problems as well. :sulk:
It's not so much the "part of Canada" as it is the type of care you need. A ER visit? Fast, and free. A family doctor visit in a very large city? Slower than in the US probably, but still free. A specialist visit? Many months. In the US it's much much less of a problem, and the care is arguably better than in Canada (heck, lots of care isn't even offered in parts of Canada, leading health ministries there to send people to the US)

----------

I'm from Canada and its obvious that our healthcare system is much more efficient and accessible than in America and its good that people are trying to change the system in America but obamacare really isn't the answer. It was all talk and no pay-out. With all the difficulties they had it ended up making it a lot harder for people to get healthcare and it just wasn't what people expected it to be.
i mean its not like some towns in canada have doctors with 25k (plus rent) a year salaries and they only take on 4 new patients every 6 months (via a lottery)...

and its not like cancer patients, etc come to the US for medical care and pay for it because it's better and/or faster...
I'm guessing this is sarcasm and if it is then you literally have no idea what you're talking about.
it's not sarcasm.

http://dailycaller.com/2012/07/11/report-thousands-fled-canada-for-health-care-in-2011/

http://blog.heritage.org/2010/02/09/the-canadian-patients’-remedy-for-health-care-go-to-america/

Need I provide more? I personally think the first report, done by a Canadian organization themselves, is the most interesting. You?

Maybe I'm missing something, but your second link seems to be against the point your making.

From the link:
"Surprisingly few Canadians travel to the United States for health care, despite the persistence of the myth."
yeah somehow i was clicking through their studies and it gave me a bad link. I was looking at one about specialty care, not at one about ambulatory (ER type) care.
 

Goddess

Where did 4 years go?!
#26
I'm from Canada and its obvious that our healthcare system is much more efficient and accessible than in America and its good that people are trying to change the system in America but obamacare really isn't the answer. It was all talk and no pay-out. With all the difficulties they had it ended up making it a lot harder for people to get healthcare and it just wasn't what people expected it to be.
i mean its not like some towns in canada have doctors with 25k (plus rent) a year salaries and they only take on 4 new patients every 6 months (via a lottery)...

and its not like cancer patients, etc come to the US for medical care and pay for it because it's better and/or faster...
I'm guessing this is sarcasm and if it is then you literally have no idea what you're talking about.
it's not sarcasm.

http://dailycaller.com/2012/07/11/report-thousands-fled-canada-for-health-care-in-2011/

http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/21/3/19.long

http://blog.heritage.org/2010/02/09/the-canadian-patients’-remedy-for-health-care-go-to-america/

Need I provide more? I personally think the first report, done by a Canadian organization themselves, is the most interesting. You?
I'm sure that's the case in some parts of Canada but not all. And the same in the US, we pay for our healthcare here, yet some parts of the US have wait times for specialists that rival those numbers.

Some specialists I've had to see in New Jersey have a 6 month waiting list to get in to see the doctor. We have our problems as well. :sulk:
It's not so much the "part of Canada" as it is the type of care you need. A ER visit? Fast, and free. A family doctor visit in a very large city? Slower than in the US probably, but still free. A specialist visit? Many months. In the US it's much much less of a problem, and the care is arguably better than in Canada (heck, lots of care isn't even offered in parts of Canada, leading health ministries there to send people to the US)
It is the part of Canada as well, where my fiance grew up a visit with a specialist took maybe a week or 2 (relatively normal for specialists), a primary care doctor, between that day and a week (again, normal), and ER visit easy.

To be quite frank, my fiance has had better luck getting medical treatment or care in Canada, than I have in the U.S.

My primary care is a pediatrician because I'm still within college age and that age range is still covered under pediatricians. I can get an appointment with him same day. An appointment with my OB? She's a primary care physician even though she specializes in gynecology, it's harder to get an appointment with her than my primary care. A specialist? I had a lot of difficulty getting appointments with specialists for varying issues I've had. Some of them told me 6 months+ waiting list to get an appointment, not even to see the doc. My fiance's had better luck than I have.
 

allison

Well-Known Member
#27
What I mean by "young people" is that, you need to have a certain amount of young healthy people, because they have to pay for the elderly unhealthy people. If you don't have enough young people, the system is going to crumble. Also, there have been many people who signed up, but actually have not paid. Obviously you need to have people pay in order for the system to not fall apart. The administration keeps saying that they won't release the numbers anytime soon, probably because the actual numbers are way lower from the numbers they've been lying about


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Monorail

Well-Known Member
#28
yeah somehow i was clicking through their studies and it gave me a bad link. I was looking at one about specialty care, not at one about ambulatory (ER type) care.

Not trying to come at your opinion personally, but it seems like you googled "Canadians come to America for healthcare," and chose 3 links on the first page supporting your claim.

It's interesting to note that links on that same google page talk about how that claim is propaganda supported and regurgitated by Canadian politicians against universal healthcare, as well as conservatives in the US who use it as a point against the ACA.

----------

What I mean by "young people" is that, you need to have a certain amount of young healthy people, because they have to pay for the elderly unhealthy people. If you don't have enough young people, the system is going to crumble. Also, there have been many people who signed up, but actually have not paid. Obviously you need to have people pay in order for the system to not fall apart. The administration keeps saying that they won't release the numbers anytime soon, probably because the actual numbers are way lower from the numbers they've been lying about


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Well I don't think registration has even ended yet for this year.
 

allison

Well-Known Member
#29
yeah somehow i was clicking through their studies and it gave me a bad link. I was looking at one about specialty care, not at one about ambulatory (ER type) care.

Not trying to come at your opinion personally, but it seems like you googled "Canadians come to America for healthcare," and chose 3 links on the first page supporting your claim.

It's interesting to note that links on that same google page talk about how that claim is propaganda supported and regurgitated by Canadian politicians against universal healthcare, as well as conservatives in the US who use it as a point against the ACA.

----------

What I mean by "young people" is that, you need to have a certain amount of young healthy people, because they have to pay for the elderly unhealthy people. If you don't have enough young people, the system is going to crumble. Also, there have been many people who signed up, but actually have not paid. Obviously you need to have people pay in order for the system to not fall apart. The administration keeps saying that they won't release the numbers anytime soon, probably because the actual numbers are way lower from the numbers they've been lying about


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Well I don't think registration has even ended yet for this year.

Actually the deadline is today. They had to keep delaying it because the numbers were way too low.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

karkat

Well-Known Member
#30
100% for an overhaul in the american medical system because the problems in this country extend far further than insurance policy makers, to the corporations what control the production of medical equipment, and the large hospitals operated liked businesses
i believe medicine shouldnt be a business
 

allison

Well-Known Member
#31
100% for an overhaul in the american medical system because the problems in this country extend far further than insurance policy makers, to the corporations what control the production of medical equipment, and the large hospitals operated liked businesses
i believe medicine shouldnt be a business

so like communism


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Monorail

Well-Known Member
#32
yeah somehow i was clicking through their studies and it gave me a bad link. I was looking at one about specialty care, not at one about ambulatory (ER type) care.

Not trying to come at your opinion personally, but it seems like you googled "Canadians come to America for healthcare," and chose 3 links on the first page supporting your claim.

It's interesting to note that links on that same google page talk about how that claim is propaganda supported and regurgitated by Canadian politicians against universal healthcare, as well as conservatives in the US who use it as a point against the ACA.

----------

What I mean by "young people" is that, you need to have a certain amount of young healthy people, because they have to pay for the elderly unhealthy people. If you don't have enough young people, the system is going to crumble. Also, there have been many people who signed up, but actually have not paid. Obviously you need to have people pay in order for the system to not fall apart. The administration keeps saying that they won't release the numbers anytime soon, probably because the actual numbers are way lower from the numbers they've been lying about


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Well I don't think registration has even ended yet for this year.

Actually the deadline is today. They had to keep delaying it because the numbers were way too low.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Right so what numbers are you expecting if it isn't over yet?
 

Jerimiah

Well-Known Member
#33
I'm from Canada and its obvious that our healthcare system is much more efficient and accessible than in America and its good that people are trying to change the system in America but obamacare really isn't the answer. It was all talk and no pay-out. With all the difficulties they had it ended up making it a lot harder for people to get healthcare and it just wasn't what people expected it to be.
i mean its not like some towns in canada have doctors with 25k (plus rent) a year salaries and they only take on 4 new patients every 6 months (via a lottery)...

and its not like cancer patients, etc come to the US for medical care and pay for it because it's better and/or faster...
I'm guessing this is sarcasm and if it is then you literally have no idea what you're talking about.
it's not sarcasm.

http://dailycaller.com/2012/07/11/report-thousands-fled-canada-for-health-care-in-2011/

http://blog.heritage.org/2010/02/09/the-canadian-patients’-remedy-for-health-care-go-to-america/

Need I provide more? I personally think the first report, done by a Canadian organization themselves, is the most interesting. You?
I'm still not sure what your side on this is as your articles contradict your previous statement...

And the second article contradicts the other two...

So again, you have NO idea what you're talking about.
 

allison

Well-Known Member
#34
yeah somehow i was clicking through their studies and it gave me a bad link. I was looking at one about specialty care, not at one about ambulatory (ER type) care.

Not trying to come at your opinion personally, but it seems like you googled "Canadians come to America for healthcare," and chose 3 links on the first page supporting your claim.

It's interesting to note that links on that same google page talk about how that claim is propaganda supported and regurgitated by Canadian politicians against universal healthcare, as well as conservatives in the US who use it as a point against the ACA.

----------

What I mean by "young people" is that, you need to have a certain amount of young healthy people, because they have to pay for the elderly unhealthy people. If you don't have enough young people, the system is going to crumble. Also, there have been many people who signed up, but actually have not paid. Obviously you need to have people pay in order for the system to not fall apart. The administration keeps saying that they won't release the numbers anytime soon, probably because the actual numbers are way lower from the numbers they've been lying about


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Well I don't think registration has even ended yet for this year.

Actually the deadline is today. They had to keep delaying it because the numbers were way too low.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Right so what numbers are you expecting if it isn't over yet?

I'm pretty sure they can give us the numbers as of now. They don't have to wait until the deadline.. I'm 100% positive they have those numbers readily available.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

acebatonfan

Well-Known Member
#35
I like the very basic ideas of it, but the execution of the Affordable Care Act was done very sloppily.

I am diabetic and feel secure knowing that, once I leave my parents' insurance plan, I will not be denied for my medical condition. Many health and life insurance companies automatically believe that, because I am a diabetic, I am a high-risk, lazy-bumm, patient that will do nothing to prevent diabetes-related complications (even when I am a type 1 diabetic who is working her rear end off to maintain a non-diabetic A1C level).

I also take comfort in knowing that I will be permitted on my parents' health insurance until I am 26. This gives me more than enough time to go through four years of college and find a job that will work for my medical needs before I am kicked off from my insurance.

The entire execution of Obamacare was poor though. Just getting onto the website to select a healthcare option was as impossible as Justin Bieber becoming a model citizen. In addition, it should not be the person's responsibility to become insured. There should be a public option that offers very basic insurance or insurance subsidies to those that want to be insured (even if it causes a minor increase in taxes), but those that wish to be uninsured will be S.O.L if something happens; if they are not insured, they will be responsible for the medical bill.
 
Last edited:

karkat

Well-Known Member
#36
100% for an overhaul in the american medical system because the problems in this country extend far further than insurance policy makers, to the corporations what control the production of medical equipment, and the large hospitals operated liked businesses
i believe medicine shouldnt be a business

so like communism


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
yeah exactly
lets rise up and storm the winter palace hello are you the czar?? bam
jump up on the tables waving bits of paper in the air
 

allison

Well-Known Member
#37
100% for an overhaul in the american medical system because the problems in this country extend far further than insurance policy makers, to the corporations what control the production of medical equipment, and the large hospitals operated liked businesses

i believe medicine shouldnt be a business




so like communism





Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


yeah exactly

lets rise up and storm the winter palace hello are you the czar?? bam

jump up on the tables waving bits of paper in the air

Please don't troll in the debate section


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Monorail

Well-Known Member
#38
100% for an overhaul in the american medical system because the problems in this country extend far further than insurance policy makers, to the corporations what control the production of medical equipment, and the large hospitals operated liked businesses
i believe medicine shouldnt be a business

so like communism


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

That's not communism

In no way did that statement mention anything about government control, social responsibility, or utopian society.

*facepalm*
 

karkat

Well-Known Member
#39
100% for an overhaul in the american medical system because the problems in this country extend far further than insurance policy makers, to the corporations what control the production of medical equipment, and the large hospitals operated liked businesses

i believe medicine shouldnt be a business




so like communism





Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


yeah exactly

lets rise up and storm the winter palace hello are you the czar?? bam

jump up on the tables waving bits of paper in the air

Please don't troll in the debate section


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
i would if u didnt take a socialist idea and immediately bring it to a far out conclusion
 

allison

Well-Known Member
#40
100% for an overhaul in the american medical system because the problems in this country extend far further than insurance policy makers, to the corporations what control the production of medical equipment, and the large hospitals operated liked businesses
i believe medicine shouldnt be a business

so like communism


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

That's not communism

In no way did that statement mention anything about government control, social responsibility, or utopian society.

*facelalm*

I was assuming that since "the problem is corporations who control
the production of medical equipment" that kind of hints to communism because it implies that the government should
be responsible for the industry


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

----------

100% for an overhaul in the american medical system because the problems in this country extend far further than insurance policy makers, to the corporations what control the production of medical equipment, and the large hospitals operated liked businesses



i believe medicine shouldnt be a business










so like communism











Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk






yeah exactly



lets rise up and storm the winter palace hello are you the czar?? bam



jump up on the tables waving bits of paper in the air




Please don't troll in the debate section





Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


i would if u didnt take a socialist idea and immediately bring it to a far out conclusion

I was just wondering if you meant communism, that's all. Not reaching any conclusions here.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Top